Allen & Stults Co., Inc.

Cathy M. of Allen and Stultz, in Hightstown, NJ, has been handling our insurance since we moved to NJ 22 years ago. We are very fortunate to have been recommended to her. She looks out for her clients. We know, we had an auto incident which was taken care of, making us feel confident that issues will be resolved to our satisfaction. We once looked to save money, $23, $41,? Nope, Cathy's and Allen and Stultz's services are worth much, much more. You need home or auto insurance? Give Cathy a call. No, I don't work for them!

I’ve had the pleasure of working with this team for several years, and their service has been nothing short of exceptional. They consistently provided superior support, whether it was quickly adding or removing vehicles from my policy or guiding me through a large claim with professionalism and care. Their responsiveness and attention to detail made every interaction stress-free. Special thanks to Cathy, Gail, and Jerry—each of you went above and beyond to ensure my needs were met promptly and thoroughly. Your dedication truly sets you apart. If you’re looking for an insurance agency that combines expertise with genuine customer care, look no further!

This place is literally the best. I had been with another insurance company for many years only to see my rates rise and rise. I wanted to switch companies and began the hunt on my own. It was too overwhelming. I contacted Allen & Stults Co and got hooked up with Katie. This company is able to look at many companies all at once to find the best fit for your own individual needs. Katie was amazing. She answered all my many questions, and made the whole process so easy. I saved about $570 with the switch. I kept thinking that I have to get to a printer soon to print out my new auto insurance card. Nope. No need. Today in the mail came a whole organized folder with my auto policy, a printed out insurance card in a nice plastic holder and a copy of my home insurance policy. Talk abou

When my car and home insurance were abruptly cut off during divorce proceedings, Maureen walked me through finding policies that worked for my needs and my budget. Because of her, I didn't experience a lack of coverage. She was responsive, capable as all get out, and so very kind. I won't hesitate to use or recommend her services in the future.

The Allen and Stults team were fantastic. I had a challenging situation in getting insurance for my business. Brent and his team did not leave any stone unturned. I really appreciated their efforts in going above and beyond to find the right insurance recommendations for me.