Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency

I was so impressed with Emma and how attentive she was. She was always quick with her responsive and very helpful. She never hesitated to run quotes for me to try to find me the best price.

This agency has such a welcoming environment and greet you warmly when entering the office. I have been a satisfied customer for over ten years. So, I can honestly say that all my questions are answered in a way which I fully understand. All the agents in the Shelby Progressive Office are very professional, courteous, and kindhearted. Thus, I sincerely recommend this office for all your insurance coverage needs.

The staff is friendly, polite and always helpful. Every year they have useful free calendars for customers on a first come first serve basis. At least two of the male agents love to talk ⛳ golf with you if you like golf. Their insurance products are also competitively priced and usually 3 different payment options are available for the customer's convenience.

Just switched my agent to SMI and couldn't be more pleased. Emma was so helpful and the transition was very smooth. She also helped me save a few bucks. Very highly recommended.

We have nothing but GREAT things to say about Justin and Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency. Justin was so helpful in securing insurance for our new property, as well as, saving us a considerable amount of money on our auto insurance. We are extremely satisfied with the service we received. He went above and beyond! We highly recommend contacting Justin for your insurance needs, you won’t be disappointed!!